Pete Hegseth is facing fury from the media darlings on the left. The left seeks to prosecute Hegseth for "war crimes" that were not criminal at the time (and it still are not criminal). The left will twist history so he can be convicted of breaking a law that did not exist.
Which leads us to ex post facto law and why it is not legal.
What Is an Ex Post Facto Law?
“Ex post facto” is Latin for “from a thing done afterward.” In law, an ex post facto law is a statute that retroactively changes the legal consequences of actions that were committed before the law was enacted. In the criminal context, it typically means:
Making an act a crime that was legal when it was done
Increasing the punishment for a crime after it was committed
Making the offense more serious after the fact
Changing the rules of evidence or procedure in a way that makes conviction easier after the act occurred
Ex post facto prosecution refers to attempting to prosecute or punish someone under such a retroactive criminal law.
Why It Is Considered Unjust or “Corrupt”
Ex post facto laws are widely regarded as fundamentally unfair and a hallmark of arbitrary power for several reasons:
Lack of fair notice: People cannot reasonably be expected to obey a law that did not exist when they acted. Punishment without prior warning violates basic fairness.
Violation of the rule of law: A core principle of free societies is that the law should be knowable in advance so citizens can plan their conduct. Retroactive criminal laws undermine this.
Potential for abuse and tyranny: Governments or majorities can target political opponents, unpopular groups, or individuals by criminalizing past lawful behavior after the fact. Historical writers (including Blackstone, Madison, and Hamilton) viewed this as a classic tool of oppression.
Undermines reliance and stability: People organize their lives around existing law. Changing the rules after the game has been played destroys that reliance.
James Madison called them “contrary to the first principles of the social compact.” Alexander Hamilton described the creation of crimes after the fact as one of the “favorite and most formidable instruments of tyranny.”
Brief History
Ancient roots: The principle appears in Roman law through the maxim nulla poena sine lege (“no punishment without law”).
English common law: Sir William Blackstone strongly condemned ex post facto laws as “cruel and unjust” because the person “had no cause to abstain” from the act when it was legal.
American founding era: Several state constitutions already banned them. At the Constitutional Convention, delegates viewed such laws as so obviously wrong that some thought an explicit ban was unnecessary—yet they included one anyway because some state legislatures had previously passed them.
Key early U.S. case: In Calder v. Bull (1798), the Supreme Court ruled that the constitutional prohibition applies only to criminal (penal) laws, not to civil retrospective laws.
Is It Forbidden in the United States?
Yes. The U.S. Constitution expressly prohibits ex post facto laws:
Article I, Section 9, Clause 3: “No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed.” (This binds the federal government/Congress.)
Article I, Section 10, Clause 1: “No State shall … pass any Bill of Attainder, ex post facto Law…” (This binds the states.)
The Supreme Court has consistently held that these clauses forbid legislatures from:
Criminalizing an act that was innocent when done
Aggravating a crime or increasing its punishment after the fact
Altering the rules of evidence to make conviction easier after the act
The prohibition applies to criminal laws. Purely civil retrospective laws are generally allowed (though they may raise other constitutional issues, such as due process or the Contract Clause). Courts also look past labels—if a law is called “civil” but is essentially punitive, it can still violate the Ex Post Facto Clause.
Note: The ban applies to legislative acts. Judicial decisions that retroactively change the interpretation of a law are analyzed under due-process principles rather than the Ex Post Facto Clauses, though extreme unexpected changes can still be struck down.
Summary
Ex post facto criminal laws and prosecutions are forbidden in the United States because they violate fundamental principles of fairness, notice, and limited government. The Constitution’s explicit bans in Article I reflect the Founders’ deep distrust of retroactive punishment as a tool of political or majoritarian abuse.
